Jerry Archer, C, 1959-62
1961-NAIA, 1st team All-American
1960-NAIA, 2nd team All-American
PSU Hall of Fame Inductee (1992)

Wes Baker, LB, 1997-2000
2000-A.P., 1st team All-American;
AFCA, 1st team All-American;
Daktronics, 1st team All-American;
FB Gazette, 1st team All-American
1999-A.P., 3nd team All-American;
Daktronics, 2nd team All-American;
FB Gazette, 2nd team All-American
1998-FB Gazette, hon. mention All-American

Richard Beal, T, 1959-61
1961-NAIA, 1st team All-American
PSU Hall of Fame Inductee (1993)

Chris Brown, DB, 1992-95
1995-A.P., 1st team All-American;
AFCA, 1st team All-American;
Daktronics, 1st team All-American;
FB Gazette, 1st team All-American
1994-A.P., 2nd team All-American;
AFCA, 1st team All-American;
Daktronics, 1st team All-American;
FB Gazette, 1st team All-American
1993-Daktronics, 2nd team All-American;
FB Gazette, 2nd team All-American

Charles Broyles, T, 1966-68
1968-NAIA, hon. mention All-American

Brian Byers, T, 1977-78
1978-NAIA, 1st team All-American;
AFCA, 1st team All-American
1977-NAIA, 2nd team All-American
PSU Hall of Fame Inductee (1995)

Eldon Danenhauer, T, 1956, 1959
1959-A.P., 1st team All-American
PSU Hall of Fame Inductee (1995)

Darren Dawson, RB, 1988-91
1991-FB Gazette, 2nd team All-American
1990-FB Gazette, 3rd team All-American
PSU Hall of Fame Inductee (2003)

Ron Freeman, DL, 1978-81
1981-NAIA, 1st team All-American;
A.P., 1st team All-American
PSU Hall of Fame Inductee (1996)

Kendall Gammon, OL, 1989-91
1991-FB Gazette, 1st team All-American

Don German, HB, 1941-42, 1946-47
PSU 50th Anniversary Football Team
PSU Hall of Fame Inductee (2003)

Harlan Hess, T, 1959-62
1961-NAIA, 1st team All-American
PSU Hall of Fame Inductee (1990)

Matt Howard, OL, 1998-2001
2001-A.P., 3rd team All-American;
Daktronics, 1st team All-American;
FB Gazette, 1st team All-American
2000-A.P., 2nd team All-American;
Daktronics, 2nd team All-American;
FB Gazette, 3rd team All-American

Tom Lester, E, 1947, 1949-51
1951-A.P., honorable mention All-American
PSU Hall of Fame Inductee (1988)

Leonard Mansfield, T, 1955-57
1957-NAIA, 1st team All-American
PSU Hall of Fame Inductee (1989)

B.J. McGivern, LB, 1992-95
1995-Daktronics, 1st team All-American;
FB Gazette, 1st team All-American

Ronald Moore, RB, 1989-92
1992-A.P., 1st team All-American;
AFCA, 1st team All-American;
FB Gazette, 1st team All-American

Brian Moorman, P, 1995-98
1998-A.P., 2nd team All-American;
Daktronics, 2nd team All-American;
FB Gazette, 1st team All-American
1997-A.P., 1st team All-American;
Daktronics, 1st team All-American;
FB Gazette, 1st team All-American
1996-FB Gazette, hon. mention All-American
1995-Daktronics, 2nd team All-American;
FB Gazette, hon. mention All-American

Joe Murphy, G, 1932-1933
PSU 50th Anniversary Football Team

Richard Overton, RB, 1977-80
1980-NAIA, 1st team All-American
1979- NAIA, 1st team All-American
PSU Hall of Fame Inductee (1992)

Ben Peterson, DE, 1995-98
1998-A.P., 2nd team All-American;
Daktronics, 1st team All-American;
FB Gazette, 1st team All-American
1997-FB Gazette, hon. mention All-American

John Peterson, T, 1964-67
1967-NAIA, 1st team All-American
1966-NAIA, 1st team All-American
1965-NAIA, hon. mention All-American
PSU Hall of Fame Inductee (1991)

Sam Pittman, DE, 1980-83
1983-NAIA, 1st team All-American
PSU Hall of Fame Inductee (1998)

Andrew Poling, DB, 1996-99
1999-A.P., 1st team All-American;
AFCA, 1st team All-American;
Daktronics, 1st team All-American;
FB Gazette, 1st team All-American
1998-FB Gazette, hon. mention All-American

Mike Potchad, T, 1967-70
1970-NAIA, 1st team All-American;
AFCA, 1st team All-American
PSU Hall of Fame Inductee (1994)

John Roderique, LB, 1986-89
1989-A.P., 1st team All-American;
AFCA, 1st team All-American;
FB Gazette, 1st team All-American
1988-NAIA, hon. mention All-American;
FB Gazette, hon. mention All-American
PSU Hall of Fame Inductee (1999)

Gary Snadon, RB, 1958-61
1961-A.P., 1st team All-American
PSU Hall of Fame Inductee (1989)

Tom Spiewak, G, 1957-58, 1961-62
1962-NAIA, 1st team All-American
PSU Hall of Fame Inductee (1989)

Gene Stegeman, QB, 1984-87
1987-NAIA, 2nd team All-American
1986-A.P., hon. mention All-American
PSU Hall of Fame Inductee (1997)

Phil Vogrin, QB, 1952-62
1961-NAIA, hon. mention All-American;
A.P., hon. mention All-American
PSU Hall of Fame Inductee (1988)

Jesse Wall, OL, 1985-88
1988-NAIA, 1st team All-American;
AFCA, 1st team All-American;
FB Gazette, 1st team All-American;
A.P., hon. mention All-American
1987-NAIA, 1st team All-American
PSU Hall of Fame Inductee (1998)

Monte Weathers, RB, 1984-87
1987-NAIA, 1st team All-American
1986-A.P., honorable mention All-American
PSU Hall of Fame Inductee (1997)

Ronnie West, WR, 1990-91
1991-A.P., 1st team All-American;
AFCA, 1st team All-American;
FB Gazette, 1st team All-American
1990-AFCA, 1st team All-American;
FB Gazette, 1st team All-American
PSU Hall of Fame Inductee (2002)

Troy Wilson, DE, 1989-92
1991-FB Gazette, 1st team All-American
1991-FB Gazette, 2nd team All-American
1990-FB Gazette, hon. mention All-American
PSU Hall of Fame Inductee (2003)

Darryl Wren, DB, 1986, 1988-90
1990-FB Gazette, 1st team All-American
PSU Hall of Fame Inductee (2000)